Winnetka's $600 Million To-Do List — and What You'll Pay
We have a problem. Costs are rising, but the Village is doing little to grow what we earn. Residents will pay more, at an increasing rate.
Tuesday, November 17 · 7 p.m. · Village Hall, 510 Green Bay Road
The Village Council holds its public hearing on the proposed 2027 budget. Final approval is expected December 1 — the same night the Council may take up the open space zoning district. Write to contactcouncil@winnetka.org.

The Village's letter to residents calls this budget “transparent and forward-looking.” For 2027, it never mentions the biggest number behind it.
This spring, Village staff identified more than $600 million in potential capital needs over the next 20 years: roads, water and electric plants, stormwater, public buildings, the lakefront. The new five-year plan alone totals $201.4 million.
That is the real budget. Every rate increase, reserve change and bond in this year's plan is a down payment on it. And the budget says the constraint plainly: Winnetka is “largely a residential community without a large commercial tax base.” Its 10 largest property taxpayers are homeowners.
OTW's view.
This is a responsible one-year budget that takes no action on a long-range bill — one with a $66 million to $87 million hole the budget never mentions. And the Council's Post Office choices make that bill harder to pay.
What the budget gets right
Winnetka's financial outlook is still good.
- Moody's reaffirmed Winnetka's Aaa rating in August.
- Over 25 years, the Village's share of a typical tax bill rose 13 percent, while inflation rose 85 percent.
- The Village has secured a $21.2 million FEMA stormwater grant and $5 million from the state.
- Nearly a third of our lead water lines are replaced.
- Downtown storefronts are about 97 percent occupied, and sales tax is up 7.3 percent this year.
And for the first time, the Council has a 20-year capital plan. Planning beats not planning.
The gap the budget never mentions
A plan is only as good as its funding. As OTW reported this summer, staff's May 12 study-session packet lists the projects one by one, sorts them by priority, and puts the funding gap at $66 million to $87 million, depending on a FEMA grant.
The problem is what happened next. That gap appears nowhere in the Village's budget letter to residents, and we could not find it in the 547-page budget book.
Ignoring the problem is not a solution, and it is not leadership.
What it costs you
The 2027 budget totals $121.8 million: $81.5 million to operate the Village and $40.2 million in capital projects. The levy rises 2.7 percent. Electric rates rise 5.75 percent; water, sewer and refuse 8 percent; stormwater 7.5 percent.
Take the Village's own example — a home with a $25,000 total property tax bill. Next year that household pays $498 more, and village taxes and utility charges reach $9,694, up from $7,864 in 2023. That is 23 percent in four years.
And the rate plans keep going. Water is scheduled to rise 8 percent again in 2028 and 6.25 percent a year after that — about 40 percent in total by 2031. Electric is scheduled to rise about 28 percent over the same five years.
Where the money comes from, and doesn't
Of every property tax dollar a Winnetka homeowner pays, only about 11 cents goes to the Village. The rest goes to District 36, New Trier, the Park District, Cook County and other taxing bodies.
Permit revenue, which Winnetka leans on more than most towns, has fallen from $4.5 million in 2025 to about $3.1 million budgeted for 2027. Construction of new single-family homes is slowing too. OTW wonders how much this has to do with the Village's new, long and arduous permitting processes.
The retail storefronts and offices we have are full. The problem is that we have so few of them, and that we are heavily reliant on residential taxes. So the budget reaches for cushions instead of fixing the issue:
- Reserves. It lowers the General Fund reserve target from six months of expenses to four. The fund falls from $28.2 million at the end of 2025 to a projected $17.8 million at the end of 2027.
- Borrowing. It plans $58.2 million in new debt for electric, stormwater and general projects. Total debt would grow from $9.8 million today to a peak of $56.1 million in 2033. The Council's own guidepost is to stay under about $60 million to keep the Aaa rating. That leaves only about $4 million of room — with a $66 million to $87 million gap still unfunded.
- Pensions. It assumes a 7.25 percent return on police and fire pension investments, rather than the 6.75 percent the pension funds recommend. A higher assumption means a smaller contribution today. The police fund is 83 percent funded and the fire fund 76 percent, together about $21 million short. Staff notes that Winnetka's funding levels are in line with North Shore peers. But overriding your own pension boards to make this year's numbers look better is not leadership. It is deferral.
- The levy. In May, the Council backed taking the full inflation increase plus new construction every year. Meanwhile, health insurance is up 16.1 percent.
Each choice may be defensible. But each one leverages the future for the present, placing a future burden on residents in their 30s, 40s and 50s. Together they describe a Village spending down its cushions and borrowing against the future — without growing the commercial and property tax base that pays for either.
Budgeting is not building
Winnetka budgets big and builds small. In 2025 the Village budgeted about $23 million for capital projects and spent $7.1 million. For 2026 it budgeted a record $39.5 million and now expects to spend about $20.5 million. Willow Road, this year's centerpiece, was pushed into 2027. With construction costs up nearly 10 percent a year, every project that slips costs more the next year.
The backlog is real.
- A 2025 sewer study found $10.3 million in needed repairs, $6.3 million of them critical or high priority, to “prevent basement backups.” The five-year plan schedules about $1 million for those critical repairs.
- More than 1,000 lead service lines remain, under a state mandate with no state money. Wilmette chose in 2024 to pay the full cost of replacing every line and aims to finish within 10 years — nearly a decade ahead of the state's 2044 deadline.
- On the lakefront, the budget says the Tower Road pier “has deteriorated and is in need of restoration.”
We need to execute with urgency.
And then there is the Post Office site
We know, we know. We bang on about the Post Office site. But here is why: the most valuable block the Village owns is an undeveloped plot of sod, surrounded by two surface parking lots.
On November 5 the Council approved a $79,890 contract, without competitive bidding, to find a partner for a one-and-a-half-story restaurant building beside a lawn and surface parking. The Village's consultants say even that plan “will require public financing,” a gap of $7.8 million to $17.8 million.
Now open the budget book, page 476. Its five-year plan carries a line called “Post Office Plaza”: $800,000 for design and $7 million for construction in 2029 and 2030. The downtown fund that pays for it, along with $13.4 million of Hubbard Woods streetscape, is projected to run dry in 2029 and to be about $10 million in the red by the end of 2031. When that fund runs out, the money has to come from somewhere else: general revenue or new debt.
In May the Council told staff to explore funding for the site, including a public-private partnership. And on December 1, the night the Council is expected to adopt this budget, it may also take up an open space zoning district that would put 512 Chestnut where commercial use is not allowed by right.
Read that against the $600 million. A Village facing hundreds of millions in repairs, with a tax base made almost entirely of houses, is planning to spend millions on a plaza on land that could pay us back. Homes, shops and restaurants there would pay property taxes to the Village, District 36 and New Trier for decades.
Every concept residents saw — including the larger ones OTW favored — included public space the Village would pay for. The question is whether private development on the north half helps pay for it.
The Council's defenders will say Winnetka is residential by choice, that residents value gathering space, and that a careful Council should not gamble on development. Fair points. But when residents were asked about the Post Office site in the Caucus's 2024 survey, more of them chose retail and restaurants than open space. And careful does not mean passive.
A Council that cannot grow revenue has one other lever: your bill.
The priority question
This is not about whether to fix the pipes, the roads or the lakefront. We must. It is about whether this Council is serious about paying for it. That means four things:
- Put the 20-year list in the budget, with its $66 million to $87 million gap, and report progress against it every year.
- Put a revenue plan beside the spending plan. Start by bidding the whole Post Office site and letting the market show what it will pay.
- Take 512 Chestnut off the open space map on December 1.
- Get serious about finding new revenue.
Come to Village Hall, 510 Green Bay Road, on Tuesday, November 17, at 7 p.m., or write to contactcouncil@winnetka.org.
So who pays for the next $600 million: a growing tax base, or the same households, a few hundred dollars at a time?
Related: Winnetka Asked for More. The Council Isn't Listening. · Three Fights, One Habit, and a Bill That Will Come Due · Winnetka Finally Has a 20-Year Capital Plan · the Open Space Resource Center